Gas V Oil

Gas V Oil

COMBUSTION

By oxidation, we mean simply the adding of oxygen in a chemical reaction.

By combustion we mean any substance, which combines readily and rapidly with oxygen under favourable conditions to produce heat.

We normally consider combustion only in connection with the fuels such as wood, coal, gas and oil, and in this particular case we shall concern ourselves primarily with gas and fuel oil.

Fuel Oil

Fuel oil is classified as a hydrocarbon fuel. It is called that because it is composed principally of carbon and hydrogen.

Combustion of fuel oil, according to our previous definition, would be the rapid combining of carbon and hydrogen with oxygen.

This is a chemical reaction, which produces an entirely new product, called heat.

As we stated above, oil is composed of carbon and hydrogen the breakdown of typical No. 2 oil shows approximately 86% C and 14% H2 by weight, therefore, the air which is supplied to burn oil gives up its oxygen to form not only CO2 but also a compound with the hydrogen.

If exactly the right amount of air were supplied for complete combustion of the carbon and hydrogen in the fuel oil, the products of combustion would be heat and a mixture of other gasses and water.

With practical equipment, however, it is generally not possible to get a perfect mixture in which all of the combustible elements are supplied with the exactly correct quantity of oxygen, and therefore it is necessary to supply what is known as excess air.

This excess air is simply air over and above the theoretical requirement for the burning of the fuel.

It must be supplied because the equipment, which mixes the air with the fuel, is not capable of bringing oxygen into intimate enough contact with the molecules of fuel to produce complete combustion without some excess air being present.

The efficiency of the particular burner is indicated by the amount of excess air required to produce clean combustion. When more excess air is required to do the job, the efficiency of the unit is lower.

This excess air takes no part in the combustion process as there is Nitrogen as well as Oxygen this Nitrogen plus other inert gasses enters the furnace at ambient temperature and is discharged at the temperature of the exit gases and carries away that much heat.

So the above tells us what happens when we have a mixture of fuel and air in the correct proportions and what it produces.

Now we must decide which fuel to use and why

All fuels are rated on their heat content, that is, the amount of heat generated when a given quantity is 100% consumed by the chemical process called "burning". This heat is measured by the amount of energy needed to raise one pound of water one degree, called British Thermal Unit or (BTU). Heating oil contains 140,000 BTU's per gallon, whereas propane contains only 91,300 BTU's per gallon. Therefore, it takes 1.53 gallons of propane to provide the same amount of heat as one gallon of heating oil, whilst this statement is true, it fails to take into account the fact that gas requires considerably less air to be 100% burnt and the resulting heat is not wasted in the exhaust gasses but is put to good use.

By contrast, Fuel oil will not burn if a match is dropped onto liquid fuel, gas on the other hand is difficult to find naturally in a liquid state to perform this test but if you did then you would need new eyebrows,

This means that the fuel oil needs to be vaproised first in order to provide a suitable gas like vapour to burn cleanly

Fuels and Ignition Temperatures

Ignition temperature:  The minimum temperature required to ignite gas or oil vapour in air without a spark or flame being present. 

Fuel

oC

Acetylene

305

Benzene

415

Bituminous coal

300

Butane

420

Carbon

700

Carbon monoxide

300

Coal-tar oil

580

Coke

700

Ethane

515

Heavy hydrocarbons

750

Hydrogen

500

Light gas

600

Light hydrocarbons

650

Methane

580

Naphtha

550

Natural gas

600

Peat

227

Petroleum

400

Producer gas

750

Propane

480

Semi anthracite coal

400

Wood

300

Calorific value of fuels

Fuel kJ/kg Btu/lb
Anthracite 32.500 - 34.000 14.000 - 14.500
Bituminous coal 17.000 - 23.250 7.300 - 10.000
Charcoal 29.600 12.800
Coke 28.000 - 31.000 12.000 - 13.500
Lignite 16.300 7.000
Peat 13.800 - 20.500 5.500 - 8.800
Semi anthracite 26.700 - 32.500 11.500 - 14.000
Wood (dry) 14.400 - 17.400 6.200 - 7.500

 

 

Gas kJ/m3 Btu/ft3
Butane C4H10 133.000 1383 Btu/ft³
Hydrogen 13.000 343 Btu/ft³
Natural gas 43.000 1000  Btu/ft³
Propane C3H8 101.000 2284 Btu /ft³

 

 

Liquid fuels KJ/Ltr Btu/gal (US)
Acetone 29.000 87119 Btu/gal
Alcohol, 96% 30.000 80,000 Btu/gal
Ether 43.000 84100 Btu/gal
Kerosene 35.000 134,950 Btu/gal
Gas oil 38.000 164.000 Btu/gal
Heavy fuel oil 41.200 177.000 Btu/gal
Oils, vegetable 39.000 - 48.000 130000 Btu/gal
Petroleum crude 43.000 138100 Btu/gal

The major problem with fuel oil is that it requires much more preparation to be combustible before it will ignite.

This means that the oil either needs to be heated to the point where it vaporises or forced into a mist that closely approximates gas vapour, This requires either the fuel line to be coiled and be in direct contact with a heat source to force the fuel to vaporise when exiting the nozzle which also requires that it be kept clean.

Also a cold furnace would be difficult and time consuming to start, if a mist spray approach were to be used then extra equipment would need to be installed, with the required necessary servicing and maintenance.

To mix the fuel oil with air into correct proportions there are several tried and tested means for doing this.

  • Drip fuel into a heated pot where it will vaporise, ignite, and thus heat the pot, blown air is also added at this point this will improve the combustion and provide heat output. This method is used but it is very difficult to regulate the heat output it will be all or nothing and the flame will be orange smoky and sooty.

  • Pressurise the fuel oil and pass through a coil of heated pipe to a jet, this method has been used for a long time with kerosene lamps and blowlamps and we have all heard of the odd explosion with this type of apparatus. It also has the disadvantage that it is difficult to heat the oil sufficiently to produce vapour, the heating coil will by nature of the device be close to the heat of the furnace, and the hotter the furnace gets the less heat is required to vaporise the fuel, this method is also difficult to regulate as there is a severe risk that should the pressure drop then the oil will rise above the ignition temperature in the heating area with severe risk of explosion and fracture, this would result in  a fuel leak close to a source of heat. however This method will produce a reasonable heat output without too much smoke and soot,  with careful tinkering this method should produce a usable heat output but it is difficult to control.

  • The most popular tried and tested method to burn fuel oil, is to spray the oil in to a mist and ignite directly inside the furnace, this method is in use in many central heating boilers around the world and is the easiest to control, unfortunately extra equipment is required to perform this task

 

Units of Heat Measurement

Both internal energy and heat is measured using the British thermal unit (Btu). For most practical engineering purposes, As stated above 1 Btu is the thermal energy required to raise the temperature of 1 pound of pure water to 1°F. Burning a wooden kitchen match completely will produce about 1 Btu. When large amounts of thermal energy are involved, it is usually more convenient to use multiples of the Btu. For example, 1 kBtu is equal to 1000 Btu, and 1 MBtu is equal to 1 million Btu. Another unit in which thermal energy maybe measured is the calorie. The calorie is the amount of heat required to raise the temperature of 1 gram of pure water 1°C. One Btu equals 252 calories.

As it can be seen from the tables above that the oil will produce more Btu’s than gas, for a given quantity of fuel, but a greater quantity of air is required to do this and as already been stated this air will remove heat from the furnace

After a lot and I mean a lot of web trawling I have come up with the answer to the eternal question of life the universe and every thing....oh sorry wrong story,

Propane, this fuel requires no pre preparation to burn and is easy to construct a burner that will burn the gas without soot or smoke when mixed with the correct amount of air, fuel oil on the other hand is very difficult to persuade to burn, as stated above several processes have to be performed in order to get it to burn efficiently, but then, and here is the really important bit how hot will it burn??

The only true method is the Adiabatic temperature ( with nothing taken away ) this method will however only give a rule of thumb indication of the real world temperature of the flame, if you are lucky

Adiabatic Flame temperatures for various fuels

 

Fuel

Formula (state)

Density

kg/m3

Theoretical air/fuel ratio

 

Higher Heating Value

MJ/kg

Maximum adiabatic combustion temp.
°C

Acetylene

C2H2

1.1

11.9 m3/m3

48

2226

Benzene

C6H6

880

13.3 kg/kg

42.3

2126

Coal (dry, mean)

85%C5%H5%O5%M

1400

10 kg/kg

28

1926

Ethane

C2H6

1.2

16.7m3/m3

51.9

1826

Ethanol

C2H6O

790

9.0 kg/kg

29.7

1926

Fuel-oil

84%C10%H3%S1%N2%H2O

850..990

15 kg/kg

44

1926

Gasoline

85%C15%H

730..760

14.7 kg/kg

48

1926

Hydrogen

H2

0.08

2.4 m3/m3

142

2126

Kerosene

86%C14%H

780..840

15 kg/kg

46

2026

Methane

CH4

0.67

9.5 m3/m3

55.5

1926

Methanol

CH4O

790

6.5 kg/kg

22.7

1876

Natural gas

CH4

0.68..0.70

9.5 m3/m3

54

1976

Propane

C3H8

1.8

23.8m3/m3

50.0

1976


 

So interestingly the flame temperature of fuel oil is lower than gas, But will produce a greater number of BTU's but more equipment is required and setting up is harder to make it burn, Gas on the other hand is not so cheap but far easier to burn and will produce a hotter flame.!!!.

So now it is decision time oil or gas well in my foundry I will use gas every time I have built oil burners of both oil pressure and spray but neither increased the temperatures above medium red heat even after pre heating with gas, and it is oily slippery contaminated the sand and foundry area and it smells horrid for far longer than a big propane leak

In my opinion the only down side of gas is cost.

for the home foundry man it is the fuel to use

But for the more dedicated foundry opperator this design would prove to have benifits, i will be building one later when the weather warms up this year (2007)

Since the composing of this page i have been contacted by a guy who has sucessfuly and seems to regularly melt copper and cast iron using used engine oil, you know the horrid black stuff we all want to get rid off from time to time.

So for more details follow this link The Artful Bodger who has written his first book on the subject...........somthing i must do too.

Any way have a look and buy the book..................Who said anything about commission!!!

Home